“This pillar critiques exclusive Jewish rights to Palestine, highlighting diverse civilizations. Historical ties do not justify displacing Palestinians.”
“The occupation of Palestinian land for 57 years violates international law and is part of an illegal colonial enterprise. The ICC’s findings suggest that Israel’s policies are calculated to bring about the destruction of the Palestinian people as a group, which resonates with genocidal intent.”
)
United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories
“The Nakba erased a people and replaced them with settlers. No amount of historical revisionism can justify this act of ethnic cleansing.”
“There once was a Palestine. Now there is not. The land theft is the foundation of this conflict.”
)
British politician, broadcaster, and writer.
“The displacement of 700,000 Palestinians during the Nakba is a historical injustice that cannot be ignored. The idea that Israel has an exclusive historical right to the land disregards the centuries-long presence of Palestinians.”
“Both Palestinians and Israelis have historical ties to the land. However, the forced removal and denial of Palestinian rights undermine any claim to a just historical entitlement.”
)
an English Islamic scholar, rights activist, author, and influencer, known for his public intellectualism on the philosophy of religion
“The Nakba, where 750,000 Palestinians were displaced, is where this started. It's a historical atrocity that overshadows everything Israel claims about their 'right' to the land.”
)
American professional poker player and businessman
“The creation of Greater Israel has systematically dispossessed Palestinians under the guise of historical justice.”
)
American political scientist and international relations scholar He is R. Wendell Harrison Distinguished Service Professor at the University of Chicago.
“Historical residence is selective for Israel. They ignore the centuries of Palestinian presence while celebrating arrivals only decades old.”
)
Egyptian-American comedian and television host
“The violent displacement of Palestinians can’t be justified by cherry-picking historical claims.”
)
British-American progressive broadcaster and writer, and founder of the media company Zeteo
The second pillar of the Zionist narrative is the assertion of a historical right, claiming that the land of Palestine inherently belongs to the Jewish people. This perspective is echoed by many Western politicians who reiterate that this land is rightfully Jewish. However, this narrative faces several logical and historical challenges:
“The occupation of Palestinian land for 57 years violates international law and is part of an illegal colonial enterprise. The ICC’s findings suggest that Israel’s policies are calculated to bring about the destruction of the Palestinian people as a group, which resonates with genocidal intent.”
United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Occupied Palestinian Territories
)
An analysis that challenges the metaphysical and historical claims of Zionism, questioning the legitimacy of its historical narratives.
)
This scholarly article explores alternative narratives and critiques the historical justifications used in Zionist nation-building.
)
Rashid Khalidi provides a detailed history of Palestine, challenging the notion that historical claims can justify modern political actions and occupation
)
Explanation: This legal perspective explains that, regardless of historical claims, international law deems the occupation and settlement of Palestinian territories illegal.
Bible Gateway – Esther 8:17 This verse mentions that many people became Jews out of fear, indicating instances of conversion motivated by fear.
The Guardian – Genetic study offers clues to history of North Africa's Jews This article discusses genetic studies related to Jewish identity and the complexities involved in defining it biologically.
Britannica – History of Palestine This article provides an overview of the various civilizations that have inhabited Palestine over the centuries, including the Canaanites and Phoenicians. Encyclopaedia Britannica
The New York Times – Raymond Aron, 78, Is Dead; A Political Theorist and Writer This obituary highlights Aron's contributions to political theory and his perspectives on Jewish identity
Wikipedia – The Invention of the Jewish People This entry summarizes Sand's arguments regarding the constructed nature of Jewish identity and the myth of a unified Jewish race.
